Wings Over Scotland | Signing up new seamen fast


As we’re a polling internet site now, a transient write-up on polls.

In a column for today’s Herald on Sunday, Iain Macwhirter repeats the frequently-produced assertion that “Boris Johnson is loathed in Scotland and is the most effective recruiting sergeant for independence considering that Margaret Thatcher”.

The 1st part is definitely real, as it has been of really considerably each and every Tory Key Minister of the last 40 a long time. But the second component simply is not borne out by the specifics.

Over (click to enlarge) is the graph of Of course polling because Johnson turned PM. It shows aid for independence Slipping from 52% to 49% through his expression in place of work.

If you price cut the Lord Ashcroft poll from a several days soon after he entered Downing Street (simply because Ashcroft is not a British Polling Council member), the graph becomes Nicola Sturgeon’s political speciality – a flat line, from 49% to 49%.

Johnson has “recruited” no person. People are the chilly really hard points.

Macwhirter also asserts (sensibly discounting any likelihood of an indyref in 2023) that “[Sturgeon] will turn the 2024 Common Election into a referendum on independence.”

Will she? She could have accomplished that with the 2021 election. She had a distinct mandate from 2016, she was driving a polling tsunami for virtually a calendar year main up to it, she could have utilised COVID as the justification fairly than letting it to be the obstacle – “This is an emergency, we have to get out now when the household is on fire” – and a good marketing campaign would have energised the motion and maximised the effect. Momentum is every thing in politics.

But she bottled it (generously assuming for a minute, for the sake of argument, that she truly has any intention of securing independence) and the chance is gone. Since that election, Yes has led in just 3 out of 24 polls.

If she couldn’t make hay out of Brexit and COVID and the mindboggling corruption and incompetence of Johnson’s administration in the past calendar year – culminating, astoundingly, in a serving Prime Minister of the United kingdom getting fined by the police for breaking a regulation he himself passed and continue to not resigning – what on Earth is heading to come alongside which is a far more persuasive argument in opposition to the Union? What is likely to provide us to the 60% that SNP folks maintain telling us is the prerequisite for a referendum we’ll gain?

In two and a fifty percent years there’s a reasonable possibility the Uk will have passed laws generally outlawing independence, fairly potentially backed up by a Supreme Court docket judgement. It may essentially be Illegal to make the 2024 election a plebiscite, never ever brain to keep a referendum.

(What we know for particular in any party is that the Electoral Commission will be totally managed by the British isles govt by then, under the Elections Invoice passed just times in the past, and will make your mind up the timing, the query, the franchise and a great deal else in any referendum that did by some means transpire.)

The SNP’s aim in excess of the past two decades has been to demolish the independence motion (so that it can not interfere with Nicola Sturgeon’s rule), not the Union. The open goal has been skipped and the ball is absent. If you’re not component of the real truth, you are part of the lie.

Print Friendly


Resource hyperlink