CLP exam cap an unfair hurdle in the way of law grads

© Delivered by Cost-free Malaysia Today

Putting a limit on the range of occasions any person can sit for a skilled qualifying test right after acquiring a degree just does not make feeling to quite a few people.

It would be comprehensible if universities imposed these types of a time bar for students to get their degrees but to have it for a qualifying test is extremely questionable.

And to impose this only on legislation graduates who get their qualification from overseas and neighborhood personal universities is not only unfair but seems to be cruel. It cuts small the aspiration of those people wanting to practise law regardless of possessing the degree.

As opposed to those graduating from local community universities and a single federal government-joined institution in the region, these graduates have to sit for the Certification in Lawful Apply (CLP) in buy to function as legal professionals.

If this double conventional isn’t sufficient, they are only authorized a utmost of 4 attempts at passing the CLP assessment within 5 decades. Only with a pass can a legislation graduate enter a authorized chambers as a pupil ahead of being admitted to the Bar.

Candidates who are unsuccessful in a single of the 5 CLP papers are granted a conditional pass for the evaluation, and are permitted to re-sit the paper but they have a utmost of three makes an attempt to pass.

Some 2,000-odd graduates from local non-public universities and schools overseas will just take the CLP examination from April 11-20.

Centered on the fact that only 20% to 25% of the 2,000-odd candidates look to go each year, some attorneys declare that there is an unwritten quota established by the Authorized Job Qualifying Board, which of system has been denied by the authorities.

For the 2020 CLP evaluation which was only held very last calendar year since of the Covid-19 pandemic, only 399 of the 1,656 legislation graduates received a complete move.

This constitutes 25% of the overall candidates, a marked improvement in comparison with the 20% who passed in 2019.

The CLP division is below the Lawful Career Qualifying Board (LPQB) which is headed by Attorney-Normal Idrus Harun.

There are thousands of Malaysians who will have to have put in massive amounts of funds to acquire a regulation diploma but who can not go into practice for the reason that they have not bought as a result of the CLP.

In influence, their legal vocation is as excellent as in excess of, even ahead of they get started out.

It must be tough for those people who experienced taken loans from banking institutions or the countrywide higher education and learning fund board (PTPTN), and painful for dad and mom who had used hundreds of 1000’s of ringgit sending their kids overseas for their degrees.

Devoid of the CLP, the graduates can get the job done as in-property authorized officers but this sort of vacancies are limited, or get the job done as paralegals in authorized companies, but that is not the profession they slogged for.

One particular law firm reported CLP focuses predominantly on procedural facets of the legal practice and it does not go deep into the actual requires of a person practising law. These regulation degree holders have to show up at courses for a very good 6 to 9 months in advance of they can sit for the exam.

He feels that most of it can be picked in chambers, a 9-thirty day period mandatory period of time in which graduates provide as pupils supervised by a senior attorney.

Getting been a master to pupils in chambers, he states the good quality of some nearby graduates who do not have to sit for the CLP is substantially lessen than individuals qualified overseas or in personal colleges.

The obligatory need for a CLP appears to be an supplemental hurdle placed by the government in the title of comprehension the community legal technique.

There is no these kinds of requirement for other gurus who graduate from overseas or from neighborhood personal establishments in advance of they are permitted to observe below, together with physicians and accountants.

Some argue that it is no fault of the authorities as these college students understood the need prior to they signed up for their courses. True, but no one envisioned the CLP to be these a complicated examination to move. Or the existence of an unwritten quota.

Ok great, it is the LPQB’s prerogative to set the passing mark or even impose a quota, rightly or wrongly. But why then limit the number of situations a person can sit? Should not they be authorized to re-sit till they get as a result of or give up? Right after all, they pay out massive exam expenses each individual time they indicator up.

Hunting at the issue from the point of fairness and equality, the federal government should really do absent with the CLP and have a common qualifying assessment for all legislation degree graduates, irrespective of whether they are from neighborhood community and personal universities or from abroad.

This will make sure all Malaysians get equivalent opportunity and there will be very little cause to complain. The Bar Council has been inquiring for this for a extended time now but the governing administration is disregarding the get in touch with for causes greatest acknowledged to alone.

 

The views expressed are those of the writer and do not always mirror these of FMT.